Ref Watch Oxford United V Charlton Athletic L1 26/08/2023 Adam Herczeg

[Sarge]

I thought he , and his two assistants were rather poor - those unpunished blatant fouls early second half were ignored - thought he was ridiculously inconsistant and both assistants dropped a few clangers too... the fact we won has no bearing - 3 from me

 

[Manorlounger]

I thought he , and his two assistants were rather poor - those unpunished blatant fouls early second half were ignored - thought he was ridiculously inconsistant and both assistants dropped a few clangers too... the fact we won has no bearing - 3 from me

I upped that to a 4 only on the grounds that he let a few decisions go and played the advantage. (prime example was Brannagan who got away with a second yellow leading to our winner)
The inconsistent awarding of fouls, despite some particularly nasty attacks by Charlton, was also a factor in the low score. An official not ready, yet, for this league.

 

[Jster]

He was pretty rubbish, inconsistent and missed a lot. And Charlton should have had a few more than their already high total of SEVEN yellows.

 

[m]

Ropey as Hell for both sides.

 

[ZeroTheHero]

Very poor. Inconsistent as hell and missed an awful lot, especially at the start of the second half. Just thankful nobody got injured as a result of him failing to crack down on some nasty (and premeditated) tackles during that period. He probably ought to have given CamBran a second yellow right at the end as well. A 3 from me, and only that because his ineptitude didn't affect the result.

 

[Marked Ox]

I thought he was decent. He missed less than most imo. And whilst he could have booked some more of their players for robust challenges, he could have booked a few of ours for stuff as well.

 

[Oxford84]

May not booked for either of his handballs.

 

[Cass63]

Booked players for innocuous challenges and let them get away with murder at the start of the second half. Cam bran should have seen a red though. 3 from me.

 

[SouthOxonOx]

Gave a couple of early softish yellows but then let far worse go. Completely inconsistent and probably not up to this level of game.

 

[Yellowecky]

Very poor refereeing at start of second half which could have resulted in serious injuries to players. Two from me.

 

[bazzer9461]

Have to agree with both you @Sarge and @Manorlounger


I thought he , and his two assistants were rather poor - those unpunished blatant fouls early second half were ignored - thought he was ridiculously inconsistant and both assistants dropped a few clangers too... the fact we won has no bearing - 3 from me

I upped that to a 4 only on the grounds that he let a few decisions go and played the advantage. (prime example was Brannagan who got away with a second yellow leading to our winner)
The inconsistent awarding of fouls, despite some particularly nasty attacks by Charlton, was also a factor in the low score. An official not ready, yet, for this league.

 

[Sir Winston]

Alas the normal poor standard we have become used to and will have to put up with for the foreseeable I’m afraid. It’s a generous 5/10 from me.